Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral

Latest Reviews


  • We originally thought the quality was great. The last year we ran into a problemwith the dough, or the pie maker and quality deteriorated. Now, they c…

  • i always order from this place and have to admit never had a bad experience. love the chicken christy the most then the roasted chicken. there steak b…

  • Like Robin said, Paradise Pizza bought out Olive Oils. Used to order from Olive Oils all the time and loved it... Paradise Pizza does not compare (and…


About

Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral serves Italian, Pizza and Sandwich. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


deliverytakeaway available

Reviews

9 Reviews on “Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral”

Excellent
4.6
9 reviews
  • Rachel

    Like Robin said, Paradise Pizza bought out Olive Oils. Used to order from Olive Oils all the time and loved it… Paradise Pizza does not compare (and not in a good way). Paradise’s pizza is very soggy and the quality of the ingredients are poor. The garlic bread, like Robin said, is just a sub roll with cheese microwaved on top. Not good. We gave Paradise two chances, and both times were terrible. I suppose we’ll have to find a new neighborhood pizzeria.

  • Jamesbharsh

    Paradise Pizza Poor Service. Paradise is going down hill now that long time owner is no longer in charge. wait times are outrageous, quality has went down hill and the new staff are not as inviting as they should be.

  • Acurry

    This place is the best! It is a true hole in the wall family owned pizza place with quality food to boot. They have recently remodeled the place so it is amazing looking! Every single time I have been there it has been amazing. The crust is hand tossed and very crispy but fluffy on the inside. They use real cheese and have specials often. I highly recommend to anyone in the Cape or Fort Myers looking for pizza.

  • MrSpoon

    Tried their special pizza, didn’t care for it at all, very greasy, cardboard like crust, jeffry was rude. However I liked the decor, fun and fresh!

  • Dre

    1 of the best pizza places in the cape I’m from NYC and they get it good old fashion pizza

  • Richard Holland

    January 2019Paradise Pizza, Lafayette St., Cape Coral, Fl., Here is my 2 cents on the food and chatter.I was lazy so I got the meal delivered.I got the broasted chicken. Which is really just fried chicken. It comes with fries.I do like this meal. For 9 bucks,It is pretty reasonable. It taste good too.The only problem which is with me. I find it too salty. I find almost all process food TOO salty for me….I just limit my salt intake. You should try it.The other great item is the stromboli. Unlike other pizza joints, which only have 3 items inside,Paradise gives you 5 items inside plus the dipping sauce on the side.You must try this.Delivery was sooner than expected food was hot.TO DIE FOR. 4/12/2013 OBA OBA OBA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Finally I found a place in SWFL that should have a shrine in front of it. A place that has REAL NY Style pizza. A thin crispy crust with great tasting pepperoni and fresh mushroom. Where the employee’s are also great and fast. The sauce has that sweet tangy taste of tomatoes with oregano and basil combine, It off the main drag. but ,ohhh so melt on the lip on of delousiness .I cannot wait till I try the subs, calzone, Stromboli and such the next timeAHHH I went back for a 2nd time. I had the calzone and a Italian sub.. Just plain outstanding. The sub had loads of meat and it was made perfect to order. The sauce on the side of th calzone was sweet and tasty all at onceParadise Pizza, Lafayette Ave, Cape Coral, FL,. Here is a bit a chit chat and 2 cents on the food.Pizza…It is a personal matter. We are fortunate to have a good pizza joints in each quadrant of the Coma.In this quadrant for me it is Paradise. My go to pizza is mushroom and pepperoni. It must still taste good cold the next morning fridge or not.This pizza has FRESH mushrooms and fully covered pepperoni slices. Crispy crust with the right amount of sauce.For me this is a lil bit of paradise. AHHH but lets not forget the red peppers flakes.I like my pizza the way I like my women, Hot & Spicy.FEBRUARY, 2017Paradise Pizza, Lafayette Ave., Cape Coral, FL, Here is my 2 cents on the food and some chatter.Broasted chicken at a pizza joint. I had a single serving meal. About 9 bucks, 4 large/heavy pieces of chicken. fries and coleslaw. It was hot, crunchy tasty….BUT for me waaaayyyyy too salty. I added catsup and salt went away. I must say it was good. An alternative for my Popeye’s if needed.Pressure cooker… thats how this is made. They serve in different sizes. Cole slaw was fine . Fries too.Tip… if you like your fries crunchy…cole slaw cold.. Then you MUST eat it at the pizza joint otherwise it all goes sideways.Oh yes I really enjoy the pizza here.

  • Jim Condon

    Awesome. Best New York style pizza we’ve had in Cape Coral. The place is still being renovated – it still needs some sprucing up and some music would be nice. Great pizza – we’ll be back.

Leave a Review

(239) 945-1555

Directions

842 Lafayette St, Cape Coral, FL 33904

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top