Latest Reviews
-
Good outside dining site, nice sunsets, good tarpon viewing, food was okay, good clam strips and wahoo smoked fish spread was excellent. We probably w…
Traveling Gopher
Islamorada Fish Company
-
Pretty average seafood. Someone needs to tell the chef that gluten-free doesn't have to be taste-free. Definitely not worth the price. Nice tarpon vie…
Lynne Browne
Islamorada Fish Company
-
Agradable parada a almorzar en los Cayos de FL. El lugar agradable y familiar, con una gran vista, mar, palmeras y arena. Hay gran variedad de platos,…
Ramiro Figueroa Araya
Islamorada Fish Company
About
Islamorada Fish Company is open for Casual Dining. Islamorada Fish Company serves Seafood dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Reviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “Islamorada Fish Company”
This place leave something to be desired. #Period Hogfish was just ok. Salad was weak, but the service was good. Good just wasn’t
Fantastic food, friendly and prompt waitress. Super water and sunset views. Very clean. Great decor. Open air restaurant. Nice bathrooms. Fun little gift shop. Great for families! Happy, relaxed atmosphere. Will definitely come back next time we’re there!
Not bad. Not great. Beautiful views. Wonderful atmosphere. Big key lime pie bowl for dessert. Share it. Service was quick and polite. Get here early. Pretty busy
Patato. Potato salis26 Apr, 2015Coconut Shrimp. Very good
Don’t let the beautiful view and the fresh fish market connected with this restaurant fool you. We ordered the crab stuffed mushrooms and they arrived not even lukewarm. They were topped with Parmesan cheese and were not even warm enough to melt it. My boyfriend ordered the crab stuffed shrimp and I ordered the crab cake sandwich. After taking two bites of the stuffed shrimp my boyfriend refused to eat any more for fear that he would vomit. I tasted the shrimp (because I didn’t believe they could really be that bad) but he was right, they tasted funky. I can’t say that my sandwich tasted awful, but it definitely didn’t taste good. The waitress was kind and understanding and removed the shimp from our bill (which is the only dish we brought to her attention as being disgusting) and offered a free slice of key lime pie. We aren’t really fans and at this point we really didn’t want it. For the amount of money you will pay, find someplace else to enjoy and oceanfront meal.
Great food, great service!
The food was good, but the service was lacking. It took over 5 minutes to get acknowledged and another 5 minutes for out actual server to help us. He only checked in on us once and never did refill our drinks. We then waited 15 minutes for him to come back to our table to close out our ticket. Not sure if we’ll be back or not.