Latest Reviews
-
This was my favorite place we ate in Key West! We had the bruschetta and the meat plate to start, both were excellent! We ate brunch so of course we t…
Kaci
Antonia’s Restaurant
-
I'm still out to lunch on this place. Be awhile before I go back.…
Donna B
Antonia’s Restaurant
-
New Year's Meh. When deciding upon where we wanted to enjoy dinner New Years Eve Antonia's wasn't our first pick but the location was good and we've h…
Sarah
Antonia’s Restaurant
About
Antonia's Restaurant serves Italian. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
indoor seatingReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “Antonia’s Restaurant”
Great fine dining! The food and service are both outstanding. I would personally recommend sitting at the bar, if you can find a spot… It seems to be the most popular place in the house. The bartender TK makes the BEST top shelf margaritas and was a blast to talk to! Definitely recommend if you are willing to spend the money.
Always a home run…. Was there the first week of May. Have been back MANY times, in fact the lasagne is so good we shipped three orders back home overnight to someone.. (They gladly packed it and we took it to a Pack and Ship place) Was $175 to ship it. Yes it is THAT good. Thanks for the many outstanding meals and great memories.
If you must eat anywhere in Key West, this is it! One of the greatest Italian restaurants I’ve ever eaten in. Out of a party of 4, we each had something different and passed everything around the table. The next dish was better than the last! Don’t pass this up
This was one of the best Italian restaurants I have been to. I tried escargot for the first time. I was excellent. My entree was the lasagna with spinach and meat sauce. It was amazing. This will be one of places I will come back to.
Service and Food Terrible. We were served by Dean, whose service was not bad, but he was not at all attentive to my wife and I. First of all we ordered the goat cheese appetizer, which arrived cold and practically tasteless. Having already ordered our entrees we simply sat there at the table and stared at the goat cheese souffle while we waited for our entree. When Dean did come back to the table and asked how it was, we told him about the taste and that we did not like it. He simply said oh well and walked away, he came back again a while later and brought our entrees, again the souffle sat there untouched, this time I told him to get it off the table. He seemed uninterested and again just walked away as if nothing was wrong. My wife tried her entree which was Fettuccine al Profumo di Tartufo, which I thought was very good, but my wife thought the pasta was undercooked and tough to eat, again Dean came the table, but this time he asked if things had improved, at which point my wife stated that she could not eat her pasta dish because of how tough the pasta was. Again Dean just walked away without even attempting to remedy the situation. We sat there for another 15 minutes attempting to get Deans attention, finally he walked over and had the gall to ask if we were ready for dessert. I couldn’t believe it, my wife had taken approximately 3 bites of her dish and it sat in the middle of the table the entire time. I had eaten my soup which I enjoyed, but Dean had already known that she was unhappy and had not even attempted to do anything about it. I told him to bring me the check right then and there. We paid it and tipped Dean 20%, having been a waiter I know that food is the kitchens fault and not the server, but Dean should have done something to make us happy. I don’t mind paying for food we eat, but the fact that we didn’t even eat half of our food and paid full price for it was unsatisfactory. We were visiting from out of town and had been told that we had to visit this restaurant, we were sorely disappointed
Excellant Food!. Great place to eat… wonderful food, atmosphere, and service…. A must stop in KW…
I love Antonia’s!. I go here whenever I am on vacation in Key West. It is delicious. I especially like the Malfatti. One of my favorite restaurants on the island!