Latest Reviews
-
Had to stop for a Key Lime sorbet and ended up with giant cookies, macaroons and fudge. Presert for lunch today. Chill'in on Duval. Save room worth a …
Chill Travelers
Mattheessen’s
-
Came here for a late night treat, and that is definitely what we got!!!! The gentleman behind the counter was so nice, and patient with us since we di…
Carrie Moore
Mattheessen’s
-
Great ice cream, very cute decor, nice staff, very clean. Wish they had more seating but space is premium in Key West so I understand :) Smelled delic…
MAMA Bookasaurus
Mattheessen’s
About
Mattheessen's serves American, Coffee and Tea and Desserts. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
outdoor seatingReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
9 Reviews on “Mattheessen’s”
Great ice cream, very cute decor, nice staff, very clean. Wish they had more seating but space is premium in Key West so I understand 🙂 Smelled delicious from street with the giant cookies.
Good cookies. The giant chocolate chip cookie was really good, nice and soft and still warm, you will get a sugar coma just from walking in and breathing as there are all sorts of treats in there and the smell is intoxicating.
Yum. Excellent
Mint chocolate chip!!! Yummy!!
A bit pricey for my ice cream budget at around five bucks for single scoop but it is good ice cream. The cookies and brownies are enormous, large enough for several people to share
Ice cream was good. Had hot fudge on banana crunch ice cream. It was average. Quite costly for the quality though. There are lots of options out there. Cookies looked great and smelled delicious.
The BEST key lime pie in KW, hands down. We have tried at least 6 different pies here, and none compared to this. Super fresh and creamy, and I won’t go anywhere else. The peanut butter fudge was perfect as well. A favorite spot on the island, and even though it has only been a few days, I’m now a regular.28 Dec, 2011The peanut butter fudge was the creamiest fudge I’ve ever had…top notch. The chocolate chip cookie was the size of my face, and was pretty tasty!