Latest Reviews
-
OMG! It was the best dinner we had in Key West! My husband had the Lasagna and said it was the best he's ever had. I had the scallops and scampi in br…
Sabrina
New York Pasta Garden
-
Worst experience ever in a restaurant!. Let me start by saying our server was good and the food was great. We were even planning to go back. But the o…
Jillschroeder71
New York Pasta Garden
-
Seafood Lasagna. Excellent dish!…
Facebook User
New York Pasta Garden
About
New York Pasta Garden serves Italian and Seafood. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
deliveryoutdoor seatingwifiReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
8 Reviews on “New York Pasta Garden”
Worst experience ever in a restaurant!. Let me start by saying our server was good and the food was great. We were even planning to go back. But the owner/manager was terrible. I have never been yelled at for requesting separate checks. Not once, but 3 separate times. Yes…there were 5 women and he was a yelling bully who threatened his server if he gave us separate checks he wasn’t getting another table. I can’t believe a grown man would treat anyone like that much less a paying customer!!!! Very unfortunate for the waitstaff. At least 3 people on the waitstaff came to us to apologize. I would NEVER recommend this place to my worst enemy.
Seafood Lasagna. Excellent dish!
Amazing food and great service. Had our destination wedding reception here in 2009. In our slightly drunken state we tipped another 20% not realizing they had already added tip in for such a large party. When we realized it the next day, we decided we really didn’t mind the $400 extra dollars since the service and food was so amazing (and we are not rich). The owner called us later the next day to say they took that extra off when they saw what we did! We travel to Key West often and ALWAYS eat here at least once. The shrimp and scallop scampi is to die for!
Sketchy Service. We had great meals
Fantastic food but very large portion sizes. Plan accordingly.
Strange misleading titles. Agree with other review but piZza and outdoor atmosphere was great
AkA Pasta Garden or NY Pasta. Very strange. Lotsa jazz poster on the walls yet they play RADIO rock station. Wait staff poor. Lobster tough. I would not go back. So much great food in KW but not here