Latest Reviews
-
The Lucys pizza in Anderson is my favorite Tuesday dinner spot! They are awesome! The staff is always upbeat and friendly! I would recommend to everyo…
Jennifer Brink
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
-
Love Lucy's!!!. Never had better pizza. Could eat daily if I could. Staff is wonderful, food is always fresh. Great variety and dessert is to die for!…
Teardrop31208
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
-
Best pizza in IF. I'm from the NE, and this is the closest there is to NE-style pizza. Not the same, but way better than anything else around these pa…
Tiffany Adams
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
About
Lucy's New York Style Pizzeria is open for Pizzeria. Lucy's New York Style Pizzeria serves Italian, Pizza and Sandwich dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
deliverytakeaway availableindoor seatingwifiReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
8 Reviews on “Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria”
Love Lucy’s!!!. Never had better pizza. Could eat daily if I could. Staff is wonderful, food is always fresh. Great variety and dessert is to die for!!! Recommend to everyone if you want fresh dough, fresh sauce and ultimate topping. Keep up the great work Lucy’s! 🙂
Best pizza in IF. I’m from the NE, and this is the closest there is to NE-style pizza. Not the same, but way better than anything else around these parts.
Ordered take out and they got the order wrong, also there is two locations so make sure the one you call is the one you want. The pizza was okay not stellar.
Great food. Ammon Branch – Lucys has a good menu and they offer delivery, Their buffalo wings and cheese bread is the best I have tasted in IF, the only thing that annoys me is when you ask for extra dressing they always forget to add it to the order. They have a good choice of food but not so good choice in deserts as the just seem a little bland for my taste.
BEST Pizza around no doubt!!!! I literally can’t eat pizza anywhere else now!
Will try to rip you off.. Called in a large flavor of the month pizza on a Tuesday ($1.50 slice day, 6 slices = $9). When we picked up the pizza, the lady tried to charge $18. When the price was questioned, the lady said we had to specify we wanted the deal when we called (which we inquired about). Who does this? It seemed obvious that if I was getting a special pizza on a Tuesday that I want the deal that is offered on Tuesdays. I didn’t know I had to tell the ditz that I wanted 6 slices vice 1 pizza which oh by the way contains 6 slices. It is shady to try to charge full price on a day when it is half price for cheese, pepperoni and flavor of the month pizza (large size). I have never heard of an establishment trying to charge more because you didn’t ask for the deal. All this aside the pizza was good but I will not recommend a place that tries to rip people off.
Exellent Service. I would like to give a shout out to Lucy’s! My first experience didn’t go as planned as I was surprised with the festive St. Paddy’s green pizza dough the day after the holiday (let me clarify that they were closed on St. Paddy’s so the dough was still freshly made that day) and upon seeing it my children and husband refused to eat it. I was a little upset that I had not been given a choice or a heads up when I ordered, so I sent the owner an email. (Which I would like to say I think it’s awesome that they are reachable via their website!) Geoff went above and beyond to make things right. I have worked as a server for the better part of my life and I have NEVER seen someone care so much for customer satisfaction. He responded immediately and was so nice! Our second order from Lucy’s was fabulous, seriously the best pizza around! Thank you Geoff and the whole Lucy’s team! Way to set the bar for local eateries!