Latest Reviews
-
Cool place. Not fancy. They brew their own beer which is a highlight! Best things on the menu is the grass fed burger and the Cuban sandwich! Their wi…
Charlotte Betts
Horse Thief Hollow Brewing Co.
-
DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME !~. If any of the realty TV restaurant shows ever came here they would have a field day with this place. POOR SERVICE FROM THE S…
Mikeyshirl
Horse Thief Hollow Brewing Co.
-
Made a special trip on our way from Milwaukee to Indy. Good food, mediocre beer (and only 3 house brews tapped at the time...bs), and not great servic…
Jake May
Horse Thief Hollow Brewing Co.
About
Horse Thief Hollow Brewing Co. is open for Microbrewery and Casual Dining. Horse Thief Hollow Brewing Co. serves BBQ and Burger dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
takeaway availablewifiindoor seatingReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
7 Reviews on “Horse Thief Hollow Brewing Co.”
Cool place. Not fancy. They brew their own beer which is a highlight! Best things on the menu is the grass fed burger and the Cuban sandwich! Their wings are petty good too! milknhonee.com
DON’T WASTE YOUR TIME !~. If any of the realty TV restaurant shows ever came here they would have a field day with this place. POOR SERVICE FROM THE START. The host is out getting Starbucks for the crew down street. Seat yourself. It then takes 3 requests to the staff to get a high chair. 10 minutes later they find one. WHAT, we are all out of the main appetizer at 5:30 p.m. Limited drink menu (No BRANDY) with own beers. NO normal mixed drinks can be found.Limited dinner menu with a chef who does NOT know town to smoke meat without drying it all out. Best of the meal; was a slice of dry sweet potato pie. Unless I become a beer alcoholic, I really don’t think I will ever come back. I hope the Starbucks was good.
Made a special trip on our way from Milwaukee to Indy. Good food, mediocre beer (and only 3 house brews tapped at the time…bs), and not great service. They can do better.
Fantastic food, great ambiance. Horse Thief Hollow has become a regular lunch and dinner place for my family. The food is great — excellent burgers, lots of gluten free choices. None of us drink alcohol, but they have a broad selection of cool non-alcoholic beverages, including their own ginger beer brew. The layout, art, and ambiance are really cool. Kids are welcome in the restaurant area — lots of families come during the day and earlier hours of the evening. The staff is friendly and welcoming. There may be a wait on weekend evenings, but it’s usually worth the wait. We love this place!
Much improved menu. Impressive cocktails, spirits and wine. The beer selection is good but geavy on ales and IPA. I liked the 18th rebellion. The only lager. Food is decent but not impressive. Excellent starters make good pub food. Try a flight of beers with the spent pretzels, boar burger or BBQ.
Finally a unique and very yummy dining option in Beverly – Chicago! Their craft beer and food is unbelievable and at an affordable price. Ive been spreading the word like wild fire because I dont want this gem to go out of business!! I cannot wait to take my kids here! Perfect for families. One side is the restaurant area and the other side is a bar. Check it out!!!
The smoked ribs were great, but unfortunately the service was awful on a rather slow Mother’s Day. Our appetizers never came, and the waitress was more interested in making sure we knew it wasn’t her fault than making sure we had a decent dining experience. Also had to wait 15-20 minutes on average for drink orders to be refilled on a slow night… When drinks are your profit margin, I don’t know how they will stay in business. To top it all off, they even forgot to not include the appetizers we never got on the check… I’d be embarrassed if I was the owner, but I didn’t even see an owner available to talk to.