Latest Reviews
-
Apple PieI am fan of Apple Pie and it was good experience at Hoosier Mama Pie Company. I loved its natural southing taste and good taste for reasonabl…
Karandeep Singh
Hoosier Mama Pie Company
-
We were early for a show at Blue Chicago and took a little walk. We had read about Portillo's, of course, so we ran in and had a Chicago hot dog and s…
Rajiv Sinha
Hoosier Mama Pie Company
-
Walked in to pick up a pie for a birthday party on a Saturday morning and I was impressed with my experience from start to finish. I inquired as to wh…
EuroAtHeart
Hoosier Mama Pie Company
About
Hoosier Mama Pie Company is open for Bakery and Cafe. Hoosier Mama Pie Company serves Cafe, Desserts and Bakery dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
takeaway availableoutdoor seatingwifiindoor seatingdog friendlyno alcohol availableReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
9 Reviews on “Hoosier Mama Pie Company”
Walked in to pick up a pie for a birthday party on a Saturday morning and I was impressed with my experience from start to finish. I inquired as to what pies were available and they were genuinely helpful and knowledgeable about all my options. Not only that, I got a seemingly simple pie in the banana creme but it exceeded mine and all my guests expectations. I’m not sure how you could make a pie better than that and I’ll probably be back for any of my pie related needs. The only thing is that this location is pretty much a take out only store. There is a single table but I wouldn’t count on it being available at any given time. To sum up, get a Hoosier Mama to impress at your next party. Or you know, eat it all yourself. euroatheart.com
Very good pie. The slices were big enough to feel full after eating. I got the maple pecan, and it was so full of flavor that I almost cried of happiness. Sadly, I didn’t govL after 6pm to get the pie flight, but boy do I wish I had!!! It would have been a miracle.
Just about the best pies ever made by some serious pastry chefs with seasonal well sourced ingredients! This tiny store has many a times seduced me with its tantalizing smells while I was innocently buying cat food from the Walgreens next door. Their selections rotate, and if you can find a way to taste heaven via their incredibly zesty blood orange meringue or their juicy pulled pork, do so now!
Not worth the drive. Even Bakers Square fairs better. Huge dissapointment!
Pies not worth the money. Good pies, but not any better that much cheaper pies or those you bake in the oven. Really, this is a fad.
Persimmon pie might be the best pie I e EVER eaten. This place is amazing!!
Hoosier in Love. I found a review for Hoosier Mama in the Chicago Reader back in 2009 and absolutely HAD to stop in since I myself am a Hoosier as well! I felt like I was home. Yes, home in the sense of being back in Indiana with my family… But also home, here in Chicago, with my friend-based-family. They specialize in comfort food… In the shape of a pie! Comfort food that not only feeds you, but warms your soul and makes you feel like you never left home in the first place. I have since gone back and tried so many varities of pies! I’ve gotten my boyfriend addicted to them as well! He loves the Hoosier Sugar Cream pie though he had no idea what it was previously, being a Chicago native. I think my all time favorite sweet pie is the Banana Cream! Favorite savory is the Pork Apple Sage! There are so many others that are great too… Beef & Mushroom Hand Pies, Peanut Butter, any of the Quiches, Beef & Stout, Chicken Pot Pie… I could go on and on… Now I just need to get in there to try the Fat Elvis!