Latest Reviews


  • Has been amazing since the first time I walked in the door about 15 years ago. If I'm nearby I always make an effort to stop in for excellent gourmet …

  • Don't listen to the sensitive haters!. By The Slice is one of the best pizza joints I have ever been to. Regarding Eric, the first time I met him we h…

  • Are you kidding me?. I can't fathom how this place manages to have ANY business. How has word of mouth not shut it down. The incredible rudeness of th…


About

By the Slice Gourmet Pizzeria serves Pizza. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details


Reviews

8 Reviews on “By the Slice Gourmet Pizzeria”

Excellent
4.9
8 reviews
  • Jack

    Don’t listen to the sensitive haters!. By The Slice is one of the best pizza joints I have ever been to. Regarding Eric, the first time I met him we hit it off and not just because I really enjoyed his pizza, but because he knew we were new to the area and his place. He always remembers us, and if he is making soup and you get to try it, consider yourself lucky. It’s fantastic, and if he thinks you will appreciate and wants you to try it, it will come gratis. He’s that kind of guy. I’ve seen him work with one arm in a sling and with no help. Eric’s his own guy and is a gem with his kids, his place, and I’m grateful we have him!

  • Hallie Tosis

    Are you kidding me?. I can’t fathom how this place manages to have ANY business. How has word of mouth not shut it down. The incredible rudeness of the owner combined with the, at best, mediocre pizza makes me give this place about a .5 or if ten.. And that’s being generous. I will NEVER return to this place

  • Kevin James

    This is a little hole in the wall pizza place across from ue. The thing to buy here is their potato pizza with ziki sauce.

  • Travlin Foodie

    Please, EVV are you kidding me? Must have gone on the wrong day. Bland, blonde crust with under cooked potatoes and very mediocre white (ranch) dressing. Will maybe try again but doubt it.

  • Nick S.

    SLICE. I have been enjoying the slice for years! Wonderful quality. The owners are nice people. The price is great. If you enjoy a good slice of pizza, stop in u wont regret it.

  • Tyler C.

    If by rude, you mean my best friend. I almost got refused service bc I ordered pepperoni. Never made that mistake again. He opened my eyes into a world of pizza on the same the level as Imos. Pizza Nazi??? I say Pizza Genius

  • Tas-2

    This is eric. Dear Readers,This is Eric I have been receiving a lot of phone calls lately about an online menu. I would like everyone to know that we no longer carry a menu and anything posted on here that says it is one is not. We only sell what is on the window that day. Please don’t call and bother me about anything you see online as it is not accurate and your questions will go unanswered and myself and the staff will most likely tell you this same thing. Thank You and I appreciate your business. P.S. My costs have gone up and I can no longer afford to keep the old prices and new ones have been established. I hope you all understand as my prices have not changed in 9 years and it just wasn’t possible for me anymore. Also when you come in please pay close attention to the rules of the buffet as no exceptions will be made to any rule.

Leave a Review

(812) 402-8518

Directions

2011 Lincoln Ave, Evansville, IN 47714

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top