Latest Reviews


  • We were in town for a baseball tournament. Roselli's Pizza (manager Antonio and waitress staff) were awesome. They were very patient and helpful w/ us…

  • I have ALWAYS stood behind this place, ordering their food for holidays, birthdays, for my company parties, and yes it is expensive for what you get, …

  • Not as good as it used to be. We ordered the Roselli's Monster (I think that is what they call it) and it wasn't nearly as generously topped and tasty…


About

Roselli's Pizza serves Italian, Pizza and Sandwich. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


deliverytakeaway availableoutdoor seating

Reviews

9 Reviews on “Roselli’s Pizza”

Very Good
4.2
9 reviews
  • Chick89

    Not as good as it used to be. We ordered the Roselli’s Monster (I think that is what they call it) and it wasn’t nearly as generously topped and tasty as it was a year or two ago. Not sure if they are cutting costs or we just got a not-so-stellar pizza, but for the price, it wasn’t worth it. Still good, but not what it once was.

  • A. Piscator

    Ate here for the first time today, and look forward to going about again in the future. We ordered the Chicago deep dish and were able to split it with veggies on one side and sausage classic on the other. The service was great and the food was tasty. My only complaint was that it needed to have more sauce. It was tasty and there wasn’t enough of it. True Chicago deep dish has a lot more sauce.

  • Djbeav

    We were in the mood for some Chicago style pizza, and we thought we give this a try. Stopped in about 8:00 on a Friday evening, no line, ordered at the counter, took a number and sat right down. Basic pizzeria menu-Breadsticks, pizza with a few different crust options, calzones, and some pasta selections. They are also offer large group sizes/catering menu of their items. We ordered a family size order of breadsticks with cheese sauce, large deep dish barbecue combination pizza , and a small Chicago style cheese only pizza. Food came in a timely fashion, and the wait staff were friendly. Drink refills were slow at times. Everyone agreed that food was fine. A few of us were not big fans of the flavor of the barbecue pizza, others liked it. The chunky tomato sauce and flavor of the Chicago style cheese pizza was a hit with my 6 yr old.

  • Prncss4irsh

    Unreasonable. This place was going to charge me a buffet price for my 8 month old baby! Just for her sitting in the restaurant! Seriously she still eats baby food! At $10 a head for a buffet we were already paying $60 for our family to eat here. The person behind the counter said that it wasn’t his rules and that was that. So RUDE! We obviously decided on a more reasonable restaurant for lunch.

  • Jillmdavis

    Average Chicago-style deep dish. We were excited to try Roselli’s, especially after a few rave reviews from friends. service was attentive and friendly, but the deep dish was average. next time I’m in the mood for deep dish, I’ll go down to Virginia Avenue and visit South of Chicago pizzeria.

  • Jenn

    Average chicago pepperoni pizza. Crust is very hard. Pizza is bland. I probably won’t order it again.the cheesecake tasted too much like lemons. The delivery person was very friendly. Ordered for delivary and very easy process with polite workers. Price was $23 for 10 in pizza and cheesecake slice.

  • Nicci L.

    Being a Chicagoland native, I am very fickle about pizza. I’ve tried Donato’s (horrible), Marco’s (decent but a typical chain), Jet’s (they’re ok), Etc. Roselli’s is amazing! Very good sauce and toppings overall. They use tomato chunks on their deep dish pizza which is great-definitely beats the traditional tomato sauce/paste. Remember, this review is coming from a true, picky foodie.

Leave a Review

(317) 228-9090

Directions

4335 W 106th St, Carmel, IN 46032

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top