Gray Brothers Cafeteria

Latest Reviews


  • ate there on Thurs. Hubby and I got fish and two sides and coffee and tea. bill was $32. rather steep since MCL purchased. smaller divided plates so s…

  • Your average cafeteria. I had high expectations for some reason, mainly because of how busy they always are. However, three people eating cheaper end …

  • I can see why Adam Richman visited here. Down home Indiana cooking. Breaded chicken livers. Stuffing and gravy. Corn. With a slice of pecan pie.…


About

Gray Brothers Cafeteria is open for Bakery. Gray Brothers Cafeteria serves Diner and Southern dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details


Reviews

8 Reviews on “Gray Brothers Cafeteria”

Excellent
4.5
8 reviews
  • Vegan Foodie Chelsea

    Your average cafeteria. I had high expectations for some reason, mainly because of how busy they always are. However, three people eating cheaper end meals & water to drink cost $46. And my food was actually not impressive at all. Very clean, friendly establishment. Very few vegetarian options (sides only)

  • Brian

    I can see why Adam Richman visited here. Down home Indiana cooking. Breaded chicken livers. Stuffing and gravy. Corn. With a slice of pecan pie.

  • Joe N

    The food was great it’s a little pricey but well worth the money their deserts are known to be great people come from all over the state to try them out I see why they do.

  • Blair Morris

    I tried the signature double cheeseburger and onion rings. Both were delicious. The burger comes with an extra bun between the two patties. They also had a pretty impressive bottled beer selection, as well as Coke/Pepsi products in cans. If you’re looking for a no-frills dining experience with solid bar food, I would definitely recommend.

  • Alan Mendelsohn

    I have reason to believe that Gray Bros. which I have been visiting for 30 years has been purchased by MCL. I too have experienced a decline in their food the last few times I visited. Their food has never been devoid of salt, as one reviewer wrote, but I thought the last time was a little over the top. There pies which were fabulous also took a bit of a decline. I’m sorry to write this about an institution that I adored, but this is the way it goes.

  • Indy.summer

    Meatloaf. The best meatloaf, don’t tell my mom!14 Apr, 2015Fried Chicken. Crispy, juicy, and just plain awesome!

  • Jakesuttonhale

    Great food. Haven’t been here in awhile!!!. The food is great, the service is amazing! I have yet to try the pies, but I love their mashed potatoes, mac and cheese, meat loaf, and their fish! Always the best at Grays!

Leave a Review

(317) 831-3345

Directions

555 South Indiana Street, IN 46158

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top