Sugar Mamas Custom Cakes

Latest Reviews


  • Sugar mama's made my wedding cake and did a fabulous job. Pricing is the beat around. I would say there is nothing they can't make. Classic Almond fla…

  • Disappointed.... We have used Sugar Mamas for the past six years. We had them make my grandma's 80th birthday cake, my sister's wedding cake, etc. We …

  • Always does a perfect job. She captures my party themes exactly, every time! She did our wedding cake and several birthday cakes over the past 6 years…


About

Sugar Mamas Custom Cakes is open for Bakery. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


indoor seating

Reviews

6 Reviews on “Sugar Mamas Custom Cakes”

Excellent
5
6 reviews
  • Indy.summer

    Sugar mama’s made my wedding cake and did a fabulous job. Pricing is the beat around. I would say there is nothing they can’t make. Classic Almond flavor is the best

  • Margo Canada

    Disappointed…. We have used Sugar Mamas for the past six years. We had them make my grandma’s 80th birthday cake, my sister’s wedding cake, etc. We wanted them to make my niece’s first birthday cake. We ordered it far in advance. On the morning of the party the store was closed. We called, and they said they never got a deposit. My sister had misunderstood and thought we didn’t have to make a deposit. That was our fault, true. But they never called, even though we had signed for the cake. So we had to frantically find a cake for my niece’s birthday party. If you want mediocre cakes that the baker is too ambitious about and service that doesn’t actually care, than this is the bakery for you.

  • Jennipher Ringer

    Always does a perfect job. She captures my party themes exactly, every time! She did our wedding cake and several birthday cakes over the past 6 years. We will definitely continue to use her!

  • Jamie Grimes Bryant

    Excellent!!!. The cakes at Sugar Mommas are beautiful and delicious. I have used them for several occassions and have never been disapointed. I highly recomend them.

  • Chloe Reese Westmoreland

    Amazing! I love going there for anything! Yum!

  • Sarah Jones

    THINK TWICE WHO YOU TRUST WITH YOUR WEDDING CAKE. UNPROFESSIONAL, WORST SERVICE EVER! After so many good reviews and referals, I thought I had found the place that would be perfect to do my wedding cake. WRONG. I set up an appointment for a cake tasting where there was no cake, only an all-knowing store front manager… not a baker. Then after giving them another chance to make me the samples and pick them up myself, THEY STOOD ME UP. I calmly called for an explaination as to why they had NO APOLOGY and then PROCEEDED TO CALL ME A LAIR. And that makinging my cake was impossible anyway. Heed my warning, do not use them. Oh, but I did taste their fondant icing… awful, tacky, sticky, bad flavor, horrible.

Leave a Review

(317) 831-0448

Directions

25 W Main St, Mooresville, IN 46158

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top