Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Latest Reviews


  • Nothing special, but adequate. Isn't the hidden dive you'd think from the name. It's a decently nice place. They are constantly infusing some liquor t…

  • The Rusty Bucket is a great place to visit for happy hour with colleagues. They do a great job servicing larger groups. I love the blueberry cocktail …

  • Meh. I ordered a hamburger here once. The patty and bun were dinky. There was a just a smattering of standard-issue fries on the plate. Another time I…


About

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is open for Casual Dining. Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern serves American dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


outdoor seatingwifiindoor seating

Reviews

8 Reviews on “Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern”

Excellent
4.8
8 reviews
  • Linds

    The Rusty Bucket is a great place to visit for happy hour with colleagues. They do a great job servicing larger groups. I love the blueberry cocktail they have. Delicious. I also like their fried pickles. Great place!

  • Katz G.

    Meh. I ordered a hamburger here once. The patty and bun were dinky. There was a just a smattering of standard-issue fries on the plate. Another time I ordered mac & cheese. At most places, mac & cheese is good. Sometimes it’s great. At the Rusty Bucket, however, I didn’t even want to finish it. How can a restaurant mess up mac & cheese?! Somehow this one found a way. The food here is bland and the portions are tiny for the price. Maybe someday there will be changes for the better, but do you want to pay your own money to find out?

  • Lee Jarrell-Melle

    Haven’t been here in awhile , had a taste for some of there great food. Not even a busy night, sat at the bar with two bartenders and not even a hi be with you in a few! Have been there when Blake is tending bar alone and still had amazing service. Guess we won’t go back!

  • Per4Mance Machine

    With the tons of travel that I do. It is great to find a great unknown restaurant! Great atmosphere, service, and the food was exceptional right down to the basic (delicious) cole slaw.

  • Lydia Kruse

    My husband and I live right around the corner from the Bucket for over a year and had not tried it until today. We were very pleased! The environment is cozy and inviting. The service was stellar – the manager (visiting from a store in Dayton) made us feel welcomed and appreciated. The food was great, and they had a nice beer selection. I know the manager would like to spread the word about this establishment to increase business, but in all honesty, I secretly hope that doesn’t happen because it was so nice to walk right in without a wait, get our food quickly, and just relax!! Either way, I would recommend a visit to the Bucket.

  • Northsider

    Smells like a frat house. I have been to the Rusty Bucket at least six times and the atmosphere never disappoints. That is, if you enjoy being stared at by the drunk patrons half falling off barstools as the bar literally hits you in the face when you walk in the door. I can’t believe the excise police let kids go in this place. I expect the patrons to catcall and whistle as my wife and daughter walk by. My friends say to give it another try, but we are done with this place. It was better when it was vacant.!! The sliders are ok, but the rest of the menu is overpriced rejects from the school cafeteria.

  • Andrea

    Good food but horrible service. We used to come here a couple times a month but the service just continues to get worse. Sad story they don’t try to hire good servers anymore.27 Jun, 2011Get the mac n cheese

Leave a Review

(317) 566-3463

Directions

1130 West 86th Street, IN 46260

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top