Petey’s Gyros

Latest Reviews


  • Sloooowwwwwww service.. My friend and I ordered at 2:00 his order came in a few minutes and he ate his food. Finally at 2:29 I went and asked for my m…

  • This place is great, everything I have tried there was really good. The burgers are homemade and the chicken strips are the best I've ever had and the…

  • Not worth it. Even for quick hot dogs and gyros you'd be better off going to any other place in town. Just one of those places that makes everything f…


About

Petey's Gyros serves American, Greek and Italian. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


deliveryindoor seating

Reviews

9 Reviews on “Petey’s Gyros”

Excellent
5
9 reviews
  • Valpo Vlad

    Not worth it. Even for quick hot dogs and gyros you’d be better off going to any other place in town. Just one of those places that makes everything from a frozen bag without doing anything creative. It’s like someone wanted to make a restaurant but disnt know how to cook so they just bought a bunch of basic ingredients at costco and thought that selling all the classic staples would get them customers. Which I guess it has since it’s still open, but I say pass.

  • Kimikhomeservices

    Fabulous Food!. Brought our work crew in for lunch. Outstanding Service! Gyro Platters were outrageous. So much Juicy meat! They should give you extra Pitas you could make three more. Our food was hot! Fast! And aside for the fact I didn’t get to play Ms. Pacman (the food was done too quick). I will bring everyone back on a regular basis. Just Fabulous! Mike & Kim Valpo

  • Kitty

    We loved it. My son stayed busy in the play area. And it was clean because I checked. I’m very particular about places with play area’s. Infact the restaurant as a whole was clean including the restrooms. And again I’m very critical of cleanliness. The girl behind the counter was nice. And we loved to food. I got the Italian beef and my husband got the platter which could of fed all 3 of us. We left full and with 2 doggy bags full ! I’m glad I ignored the couple of other reviews I wanted to give it a chance. And only bad thing is I’m sorry I hadn’t found it sooner. We most defiantly will be back.

  • Fat Boy

    Dry meat, slow service, play area is grossly sticky. There is a stench like a diaper was left behind the pop machine. Seems to be no owners onside; just kids working behind the counter. Pity

  • Eric

    Not worth it.. I drove 25 minutes to try this place out on a recommendation only to find out the gyro platters are about $1.50 more here than anywhere else. There was a real stench by the drink machine and the place wasn’t really clean. The gyros weren’t spectacular nor was the service. The 99 cent hot dog special they had wasn’t a bad deal.

  • HoosierEpicure

    Good, but…. Since this place is within a stone’s throw of my office, I eat here with some regularity. I love gyros and their’s are fine. Everything I have had here is up to par with a joint of this caliber… except the hot dogs.You know, every once in awhile I get a craving for a hot dog. Not often or I’d be even bigger than I am already. I went to Petey’s today and had the combo with two dogs: they were lukewarm and had a funky color to them. They were the Anti-Dogs, enemy to fine upstanding hot dogs everywhere.The fries are nothing special although they do supply you with a large portion. The place, including the restrooms, is clean… always a good thing. Prices are on the upper end of reasonable for this type of restaurant. Verdict: I will stick with the gyros and not be disappointed again. (By the way, I still miss the former occupant of this spot: Schlotzskys.)

  • Tina

    Very good but could be better. We eat at Petey’s about every other week. Love the gyros, greek salad and lemon rice soup. Having grownup in Detroit and addicted to the food in Greek Town, I’m missing a few things that should be at Petey’s. Petey, you have gyros and no spinach pie? You serve gyros but I can’t get Chicken Souvlaki? You have chilidogs, but really they should be coneys. We’ll be back again and again but I can’t help but think that you’;d be busier if you made a few adjustments.

Leave a Review

(219) 548-2233

Directions

255 Morthland Drive (RT 30), Valparaiso, IN 46383

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top