Old Mill Restaurant Incorporated
Latest Reviews
-
WE hired the Old Mill Restaurant to cater my Daughters wedding this past Saturday April 28th. We were very disappointed in the food as well as the rud…
Carey Meredith
Old Mill Restaurant Incorporated
-
Food ?. I have had been in a wedding recently that had their rehearsal dinner there. They did not have what seemed enough of the fish or chicken they …
-
Worst Caterer EVER!!!!!. I hired the Old Mill to cater my daughters wedding in June. When I contacted them a week before the event they were confused …
Anita Pettigrew
Old Mill Restaurant Incorporated
About
Old Mill Restaurant Incorporated serves American and German. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
indoor seatingReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
4 Reviews on “Old Mill Restaurant Incorporated”
WE hired the Old Mill Restaurant to cater my Daughters wedding this past Saturday April 28th. We were very disappointed in the food as well as the rudeness of the owners. I have been in this business myself for 30 years. And this was the msot disappointed I have ever been in a vendor. Our fried chicken was burnt, the rolls were burnt and cold, mashed potatoes, gravy and corn had no seasoning. The bartender was very rude to several people and it just added to the negative experience. Numerous people tried to tell them, when asked, by what they thought of the food, but nothing was addressed or was rudely dismissed. The Old Mill used to be a staple in the tri-state, but I do feel the quality and customer service is on a fast decline. They should have at least offered some kind of refund for ruining one of the most significant parts of the reception. As a wedding professional, planner and floral designer, I was embarrassed. But as the Mother of Bride, I am beyond angry and disappointed. I will NEVER recommend this establishment to anyone. Carey MeredithAlyssa & Randall Sanders
Food ?. I have had been in a wedding recently that had their rehearsal dinner there. They did not have what seemed enough of the fish or chicken they had ordered. It was not even warmed when the food was served and got to my seat. The dessert I thought would be decent and tasted like I ate a mouthful of pie filling that was not seasoned.
Worst Caterer EVER!!!!!. I hired the Old Mill to cater my daughters wedding in June. When I contacted them a week before the event they were confused about the time of the meal. The day of the event I had ordered tea, lemonade and water to be served as the beverages and we were served soda out of 2 liter bottles. When I received my credit card statement after the event I was overcharged $500! I had paid a $500 down payment months before the event but apparently Sandy forgot about that! Now we are trying to contact them to get an itemized bill explaining the extra charges and have been given every excuse in the book! I wish I would have used the Bauerhaus as I had first intended!!!!!
Thoroughly mediocre.. The service was terrible, the food was thoroughly unremarkable, and the atmosphere was blase. We had to send our meat entrees back multiple times before they were cooked as we had ordered them, and our server’s attitude left something to be desired. All in all, I felt as if I would’ve had a more pleasant (and flavorful) dining experience had I stayed at home.