Stoll’s Country Inn South

Latest Reviews


  • Chicken is excellent I am guessing broasted not fried. Plenty of main dishes to chose from. I would agree with some reviewers that the veggies are a l…

  • Noticed this place on the highway and dropped by because it's an Amish buffet. It's a cute family owned business with a really cool gift shop. The buf…

  • My son and I arrived at Stoll's a little after 7 on Saturday night. The parking lot was full, but we were seated immediately. Our server came over and…


About

Stoll's Country Inn South is open for Casual Dining. Stoll's Country Inn South serves Diner dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


indoor seatingno alcohol available

Reviews

8 Reviews on “Stoll’s Country Inn South”

Excellent
4.9
8 reviews
  • Hania Osta

    Noticed this place on the highway and dropped by because it’s an Amish buffet. It’s a cute family owned business with a really cool gift shop. The buffet is not bad. They have a salad and soup booth, a fish and meats booth and a dessert booth

  • Cate Sisco

    My son and I arrived at Stoll’s a little after 7 on Saturday night. The parking lot was full, but we were seated immediately. Our server came over and told us to help ourselves to the buffet. They had a nice small salad bar. The only lettuce they had was shredded lettuce. They had two hot bars and a dessert bar as well. I had a boneless fried pork chop and a piece of fried chicken, both were very good. For my sides I tried the mashed potatoes and white gravy, corn, green beans, and Amish noodles, plus a piece of the fresh baked white bread. We did not make it to the dessert bar, just to darn full. Buffet price wast $13.45 each plus the cost of the drink. Good meal, but we ate too much!

  • Leah Webber

    Best food ever! It was the best way to end our road trip from St. Louis to Indiana now to head back home. The fried chicken and pork chops were amazing!

  • Russ

    The chicken and dessert is the only good part of meal, they have really gone down hill in the past two years. Make an effort to visit the other Stoll’s (no relationship-name only) by the lake and checkout how this place used to be before they got cheap with poorer quality good & veggies that taste like they are from the can /- yuck

  • Heather Williams

    Horrible food, worse than school cafeteria food. Will not ever go back!

  • Jeanna

    Good food friendly staff love the chicken and the chops , hubby’s said salmon patties on fri night r great worth the drive from Evansville for a good meal. Nice to have a place that don’t over season the food that’s what the salt and pepper is for if u want it been many times will defiantly return many times<3

  • Urban City Food Lover

    Not Sure How They’re Making It. I have tried this place several times. Each time it’s not been a good experience. I apparently can’t say what we’ve experienced for my review will be deleted but I can say my friends and my family will not be going back. You know, everyone who has any common sense knows that if you sacrifice quaility item for lower price items you are going to get exactly what YOU pay for, that’s the bottom line folks.Not worth the drive from Evansville!

Leave a Review

(812) 867-7730

Directions

19820 Castle Creek Dr, Evansville, IN 47725

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top