Latest Reviews
-
I have to agree with others on the pizza's here are overpriced and they're Bland Bland Bland they give you very little toppings and they charge an ove…
Dwayne Hart
A & A Pagliai’s Pizza
-
Blander than bland. Such a disappointment! The crust is a tasteless cracker-type material (more reminiscent of Civil War-era hard tack than pizza crus…
Carlosdesmondk
A & A Pagliai’s Pizza
-
Like the Colonel, they do one thing and do it well, but at PAUL-ee-eyes it's great pizza, tasty crisp crust and fresh ingredients - no sides, no salad…
Diddy
A & A Pagliai’s Pizza
About
A & A Pagliai's Pizza serves Pizza. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Reviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “A & A Pagliai’s Pizza”
Fab Pizza. Nothing special here- other than the fabulous ‘Za that these people create! If you crave appetizers and sides, it’s not the place to go. But then again, once the pizza comes out -hot and tasty- all sins are forgiven! 🙂 Outstanding pizza!
This place is an Iowa City icon from the decor to the food. Pizza doesn’t get any better than this.
As a transplanted east coaster, I cannot understand the appeal of this place. This is essentially frozen pizza. Served in a restaurant. Save the cash, drop into HyVee, and grab a Tombstone.
Not like Chicago thin crust!. I have lived in Chicago,Illinois and Scottsdale,Arizona and wanted thin crust pizza. The crust was good(not great) and the toppings were fresh and good quality. It was not over spiced and it had a nice color(not over or under cooked). The restaurant is very small,tightly packed/crowded. Not very organized in the kitchen/pizza making area. I would try it again, just not on a busy weekend.
Ate here only because everyone said it was an Iowa City tradition. However we were not that impressed with the pizza;rather bland sauce and really nothing special.
Overpriced and average at best. It’s no secret that Pagliai’s stocks the front with dozens of frozens pizza, which isn’t surprising, as their pizza tastes like a frozen, grocery store pizza. Crust is bland and papery in texture, sauce is weak and topping choices are limited.
Overrated. Not really any great pizza places in Iowa City