Latest Reviews
-
Food mostly fine, but crab soup, which they call 'best' is too pasty and not very crabby. The waitress did not give prices when she revewed specials. …
Stan
Carrol’s Creek Cafe
-
Went for lunch. Got the pan seared scallops. Delicious. Great view and nice atmosphere on the deck. Very good service. Also tried a special. Not as go…
Raymond Boncek
Carrol’s Creek Cafe
-
Great restaurant! Food is to die for came here twice on my vacation. Bill for three people was 100$ including a bottle of wine appetizers and dinner. …
Ariana Zebrasky
Carrol’s Creek Cafe
About
Carrol's Creek Cafe serves Seafood. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
outdoor seatingwaterfrontReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
9 Reviews on “Carrol’s Creek Cafe”
Great restaurant! Food is to die for came here twice on my vacation. Bill for three people was 100$ including a bottle of wine appetizers and dinner. Atmosphere is great servers are great over all great experience.
It had been a while. Had not been there in a number of years and was pleasantly surprised at the still fine food and service. The small plates a great addition which we loved especially the scallops, delightful and mouth watering. Everything was terrific including service. We will definitely return when back in town.Milton foodies
Huge Disappointment. I dined with my dad and DH (2 June 2013) for brunch. My dad made reservations for 1pm but I asked him to change it to 12:30pm since we would be getting to the restaurant earlier than planned. We were greeted warmly by the hostess. We were given a table next to a window but unfortunately it was in the closed off room, so the noise level was extreme due to the number of people in the room. A full brunch is served from 10am to 1:30pm and the price includes a complimentary mimosa or bloody Mary. I wish we had reservations for 11am-11: 30am timeframe. When we went to the buffet, we noticed lots of almost-empty platters. The poached salmon was just about gone and never replaced (what little I could pick from the bones was very good); the roast beef was tough to chew, even when thinly sliced; there were probably a dozen chilled shrimp floating in a large bowl, where the ice had melted (also never replaced). The seafood risotto included calamari, which okay but there was no other seafood to be found. There was a chicken dish in a white sauce, but the meat was dry. The soup container was almost empty. Other items were not appetizing looking. You can have a made to order omelet or eggs Benedict. DH and I ordered the eggs Benedict, which was the only thing I really enjoyed. The dessert table was pitiful. Most of the pies and cakes were gone and the flan, the only dessert I really wanted was gone and not replaced. I had a brownie and a bite of their carrot cake (my carrot cake is ten times better than theirs). Our waiter was fine and the room finally quieted down after most people left. Weve had brunch here in the past and thought it was very good to excellent. This visit was a big disappointment. I dont think this brunch was worth what we paid ($30pp with tax and tip) and will probably not return unless we arrive closer to 11am when the food is fresh and the platters are not bare bone, and will ask to sit in an open area to avoid the high noise level of customers.
Wonderful atmosphere. Rockfish was so delicious. Wait staff efficient and pleasant
Great for seafood lovers.. This place has a great seafood selection. Pricey, but great food and great ambience. Fantastic view too. Not much to choose from if you don’t like seafood, though. And both ‘land’ entrees (chicken breast and filet mignon) come with mushrooms…so if you don’t like seafood or mushrooms, you’re SOL. Otherwise, great menu and delicious food. I strongly recommend the scallop appetizer. TO DIE FOR! I had it as an entree with a side salad and it was plenty.
Rockfish w/crab meat tops. Totallyt top restaurant for this meal. light sauce, balance of crab and rock fish perfect.Very hard to get a decent cup of expresso or decafe coffee.Very good Oysters Rockfeller first course.
Nice view of the water, friendly staff.. We enjoyed our dinner sitting outside. The waiter was extremely friendly an service was great. The crab cakes and scallops were delicious.