Latest Reviews
-
Pretentious. Stopped in for dinner. Host was seated at his control desk, we asked for a table for two, guy just kinda looked through us as if we didn'…
Tgregorywest
Atlantic Fish & Chop House
-
Fabulous setting right on the water. Food was only fair. Lobster roll consisted of frozen lobster meat (host assured us it was fresh when we enquired …
Elizabeth
Atlantic Fish & Chop House
-
Completely overrated. They skimp on wine pours. The oysters are fresh, but the shucking leaves something to be desired. The broth in the muscles is he…
Epicurious
Atlantic Fish & Chop House
About
Atlantic Fish & Chop House serves American, Seafood and Steak. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Reviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “Atlantic Fish & Chop House”
Not impressed at all. First, menu is a la carte. For $40-50 per entree it SHOULD come with some sides. Or at least a salad. No to both. Each side is $9 – so if you don’t mind paying almost ten bucks for some spinach or a potato maybe you’ll like this. $19 for a bowl of mediocre chili??? $44 for fatty pork shank that was almost impossible to physically eat. Really??? Food was nothing special at all and our waiter kept pushing us to order drinks, apps – and the more expensive entrees. We did not like the pushiness. Would not recommend at all. Plenty of other places to eat here that are way better values. We had amazing brunch for $28 at Water st at Harborview Hotel on Sunday and $35 for twin lobsters including wonderful lobster bisque and 10 shrimp cocktail at the fish market in Menemsha. I guess the 65% rating says it all…
Ate here twice this year, once for late lunch and once for dinner. Best Bloody Marys (just like last year)! Great burgers and appetizers. Dinner varies but incredible veal chop, seafood, steaks. Like many restaurants in Edgartown – very expensive but great location and service. You can eat casually at the bar, on the water or in the dining room.
Great food. Applebee’s?? Puhleez. Large portions. Great knowledgable service. Nice location. Thumbs up!
Poor food. Like going to Applebee’s but with worse service and a much pricier menu. Pretty views though!
The best restaurant on the Vineyard. Amazing food, service and atmosphere.
All atmosphere.. Could be considered one of the best locations in Edgartown … and the view of the harbor is absolutely great. The food, not so much.
Nothing special. We went there for drinks and it was very bland. I will try it again, but am not that impressed.