Jim Dandy’s

5 Reviews on “Jim Dandy’s”

• Chuck

  I have gone here and got take out. It’s ok. Nothing special. Kid friendly.

  January 29, 2014, 9:30 pm

  Log in to Reply
• Josh R

  Worst burger ever. I ordered some food for pick up yesterday from the Nutley Jim Dandy’s, two bacon cheeseburgers, a turkey burger onion rings and potato skins. Upon opening the burgers we were surprised to find that there was no lettuce tomato, onions etc. I called and was told all these must be asked for, going against all standards of burger ordering. Usually these things are put on unless asked not to have them. Looking past this first disappointment we at least hoped for some better than average burgers, at least better than a fast food burger from Wendy’s lets say. The bacon was burnt so bad it could have chipped a tooth, and they were able to get a taste from the burger i haven’t tasted since the old middle school cafeteria, i can only guess this is achieved by leaving a over cooked burger on a counter, or dirty bowl, for many hours. I was also amazed to find that onion rings could be made to resemble rubber, i have no idea how this was achieved. The bread though fresh was of the lowest quality. The only thing they didn’t completely screw up was the potato skins, they were at least average, way to go. Over all we felt like we got robbed, you wouldn’t think simple food could go so wrong. The staff at Jim Dandy’s obviously has no pride in there work, how do places like this stay in business?

  March 21, 2013, 7:43 pm

  Log in to Reply
• BF

  I visit this location at least monthly with a small group of friends to eat and drink in the bar area. Not upscale but comfortable setting. Food is excellent at a relatively low price. The taps are clean and cold. All the bartenders have been attentive and nice.

  August 19, 2012, 11:35 am

  Log in to Reply
• George Zaky

  Been to the North Arlington…. Been to the Lyndhurst location and it was great and the people were nice and friendly; a month later decided to order carry out from the Nutley location and it was just terrible, the burgers were just way overcooked and dry and the guy behind the counter with that nasty hairpiece was just very rude and careless, he made me wait an extra 10 mins while he was on the phone and it was unacceptable cause the longer I waited the longer the food sat there… So when I finally got his attention I asked if I can add a milk shake to my order and he rudely and sarcastically replied saying they stopped making shakes 10 years ago… Maybe it was the hairpiece on top of his head put on too tight but it wasn’t in any way shape or form an enjoyable experience for me… Highly recommend the Lyndhurst location but definitely DO NOT recommend the Nutley one

  February 21, 2011, 7:09 am

  Log in to Reply
• Chiara D

  I am no longer a meat eater, but would have to say this is one of the places I miss! Ribs are cooked just right and fall off the bone perfectly

  May 3, 2009, 10:50 pm

  Log in to Reply