Mustachio’s Pizza

Latest Reviews


  • New to the neighborhood and decided to give Mustachios a try. The pizza was very tasty. Nice big slices and spicy pepperonis. *two thumbs up* I forwar…

  • Nasty. Pizza was soggy and greasy, wings were overcooked and tiny and tasted like they came out of a dirty fryer, subs had no meat. employees were rud…

  • Just had pizza and wings delivered on a Sunday night....perfect!…


About

Mustachio's Pizza is open for Fast Food. Mustachio's Pizza serves Italian, Pizza and Sandwich dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


deliverytakeaway availableprivate parkingindoor seatingno alcohol available

Reviews

7 Reviews on “Mustachio’s Pizza”

Excellent
4.9
7 reviews
  • Jeffrey Christopher Hunt

    New to the neighborhood and decided to give Mustachios a try. The pizza was very tasty. Nice big slices and spicy pepperonis. *two thumbs up* I forward to trying other items on the menu.

  • Shanemichaels4

    Nasty. Pizza was soggy and greasy, wings were overcooked and tiny and tasted like they came out of a dirty fryer, subs had no meat. employees were rude on the fone and in person. next time I”ll just go to burger king.

  • Ken

    Just had pizza and wings delivered on a Sunday night….perfect!

  • Joe Gioele

    Gross. Idk what it is about the pizza but its just gross. its way way under seasoned the sauce taste like tomato sauce from a can. And the wings are mushy and the BBQ sauce is too sweet. At least its cheap and they gave plenty of bleu cheese. I WONT be going back.

  • Munchonmuff

    Awful.. Bad. Really bad. Went in there tonight and was shocked by how bad it was. It reminded me of the food they gave us at Bennett H.S., only much worse. Is was gonna just hang up when the little punk on the phone gave me a hard time when I ordered, should have gone with my original instinct

  • Richard Crainium

    Not recommended. Food was nasty as hell, and the staff were real pricks, especially the tatted-up guy that made me wait nearly 10 minutes for food that was already cooked when I walked in. Owner seemed like a jerk too, and the place wasn’t very clean either.

  • Elena Rizzo

    Awesome pizza

Leave a Review

(716) 874-8909 (716) 874-8909

Directions

2701 Elmwood Avenue, NY 14217

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top