Latest Reviews


  • This may be the best burger I've had in the Hudson Valley, and I recommend a Hurricane Kitty, a hearty IPA from Keegan Ales to complement it.…

  • The beer is pretty good, and the space is nice. The food, however, is abysmal. Everything I've ever ordered from here tasted like it was out of the bo…

  • Not interested. Just had the worst customer service experience while attempting tomake a reservation.So rudely snubbed by the douche manager,Carl. I h…


About

If Gilded Otter Brewing Co has incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


live music

Reviews

9 Reviews on “Gilded Otter Brewing Co”

Very Good
4.4
9 reviews
  • Asauschuck

    Not interested. Just had the worst customer service experience while attempting tomake a reservation.So rudely snubbed by the douche manager,Carl. I have made the choice to never come to your establishment…because i am the customer!

  • Ccbean

    Nice. Enjoyed the service and food overall. Burger was great!

  • Mike C

    These guys really need to update their menu and beer… Iys getting old guys. Bring in some new chefs to revamp, you have to compete with mill house brewery now who takes the cake by a landslide. Beers constantly changing and the food is amazing.

  • Kate

    Once was enough.. Good atmosphere and beer list but the food is just not good!

  • John

    The gilded otter has terrible service and the food isn’t that great. Waiter ignored my wife and I the entire time we were there. Had to ask another waiter to bring us more drinks and even went to the bar to get them ourselves.

  • G-Burke

    Food and atmosphere are great, very cool open-look with brew kettles and fermentation tanks all over. Main complaint I have is the beer. Sadly, the beer doesn’t stand up at all: weak Scotch Ale (tasted like a pumpkin, while the pumpkin tast like they spilled a can of all spice in it) and the lager is very watery and lacks flavor. I do have to commend the porter though; great notes of chocolate and coffee. Overall, the good and look of the place will bring me back.

  • 2gneiss

    Neat Place!. Loved the atmosphere. Food was good. Love that they have fried cheddar cheese. Service was good.

Leave a Review

(845) 256-1700

Directions

3 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top