Blue Horizon Diner Restaurant

Latest Reviews


  • Restaurant service is horrible my waitress was rude as soon as I sat down I was by myself she had blonde hair talks like a robot sounds funny I went t…

  • I love this diner! I live on long island and everytime im up in Monticello i make sure to have a meal there. The prices are reasonable and the service…

  • Love the Blue Horizon. Lived here for years and go to the Blue often. Its great!typical diner food, but of course with Greek Specialties.Worth trying.…


About

Blue Horizon Diner Restaurant serves Diner. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details


Reviews

6 Reviews on “Blue Horizon Diner Restaurant”

Very Good
4.2
6 reviews
  • Butter Leaf

    Restaurant service is horrible my waitress was rude as soon as I sat down I was by myself she had blonde hair talks like a robot sounds funny I went there couldn’t decide what I wanted her first rude comment was you looked at the menu 8 times already didn’t know there was a limit and second she never checked on me to see how I was doing after I ate she told me she made my banana split already remind you its sitting out and I didn’t know and as soon as she gave it to me it was melted already horrible service everytime I call to speak to the owner she is never there will never go back save your time and go to miss monticello Burgers are amazing and waitresses there actually know how to make a banana split also Liberty Diner is better never been to Tillys But Miss Monticello and Liberty Diner are my faviorite

  • Harry Reznik

    I love this diner! I live on long island and everytime im up in Monticello i make sure to have a meal there. The prices are reasonable and the service is great

  • Lass

    Love the Blue Horizon. Lived here for years and go to the Blue often. Its great!typical diner food, but of course with Greek Specialties.Worth trying. Waitresses very friendly, and prompt. During summer it gets crowded, maybe then more people are apt to write lousy reviews but i found itfine. Nice staff.

  • Annonomous

    Awful. The food and the service here is horrible. I asked for a well done burger, and it was still red on the inside they took it back, and re-cooked the same burger that I had already taken a bit out of. Talk about horrible food.

  • John

    Service and food are awful. Waited 40 mins for eggs, order was all wrong and food was cold. They didn’t do anything to make it right. offered dessert which we Declined as we couldn’t even eat our dinner. So called manager needs training in customer service. Will never eat here again

  • Chasmv

    I wish I liked this place. But the food is just average (the fish cakes were downright AWFUL!), the service is perfunctory, and the coffee is weak. Oh well….

Leave a Review

(845) 796-2210

Directions

4445 State Route 42, Monticello, NY 12701

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top