Latest Reviews
-
Best pizza in Reynoldsburg! The price is spot on, fresh ingredients (grown in front of the shop), and great people! Not really a place to dine in unle…
Stacievans2016
Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery
-
Very good!. Cheese danish on croissant dough? Yes Please! Very happy with my purchase.…
Amanda Reno
Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery
-
This was my first try at Tyler's. I ordered a regular pepperoni pizza. No extras. It was fantastic! The wood fired oven along with the very fresh ingr…
About
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery is open for Pizzeria and Bakery. Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery serves Pizza and Bakery dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
takeaway availableindoor seatingno alcohol availableReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
8 Reviews on “Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery”
Very good!. Cheese danish on croissant dough? Yes Please! Very happy with my purchase.
This was my first try at Tyler’s. I ordered a regular pepperoni pizza. No extras. It was fantastic! The wood fired oven along with the very fresh ingredients made a superior pizza. I sampled some cinnamon walnut bread while I waited for my pizza and it was excellent as we’ll. I will definitely be back ( regularly).
Decent. Just finished a large pizza. Mushroom with half sausage. The sausage was very good! Nice and spicy with good flavor. Mushrooms were the typical mushrooms that just about every other pizza joint has. Nothing special. The sauce was the star of this pizza! Would have liked to see the crust a little more crisp. Like this place. Mostly a bakery with all kinds of breads and pastry’s. Since we ordered when we got there we got to sample! Would order pizza again but would ask for the crust to be crispy. This is a take out only place unless you want to sit at a table outside on the sidewalk.
Excellent!. The pizza was delicious,i’m italian and i was a pizza cook,so i know what i am talking about.The dough is made daily,the tomato sauce is fresh and homemade and you can really taste the difference of something cooked in the wood fired oven.Really a 5 stars pizza.The people also was very friendly and they offer us some sample of the others goodies,everything was very good and had that taste of… homemade by Grandma!That little place worth a try.
Service was outstanding got to try out some bread while I waited for my pizza defiantly the friendliest people I have ran into since I have been in Columbus highly recommended
I discovered Tyler’s Pizzeria and Bakery back in March. At that time I was simply in love with the atmosphere, friendliness and quality of food. 6 months later, and this has turned into my favorite spot in Reynoldsburg. Walking into Tyler’s is almost like stepping back in time. They are patient, nice and go above and beyond for their customers! My little ones love it just as much as I do! I have been ordering baked goods for my kindergartener’s class room parties. I spent hours running to 4 different grocery stores to find a treat for my daughter and her classmates, some of whom are allergic to peanuts. I gave up and stopped into Tyler’s. What a relief it was to know that they are a peanut free bakery! Their pizza is delicious, chocolate chip blueberry bars and zucchini bead were a huge hit with the kids! Their scones are perfect and their cookies are addicting! When I want to surprise my children with a special treat, I always stop in. Wonderful and you are sure to walk out satisfied!
Awesome Pizza & Baked Goods. I visited Tyler’s for the first time yesterday, and was very impressed with the service and the food. They cook everything in a brick oven, and while I was waiting for my pizza I was offered samples of their baked goods. The cinnamon raisin swirl bread was delicious! I ended up buying a loaf of it to take home as well. I got a large pizza with 5 toppings, which would cost an arm & a leg at most places, but I think their prices are extremely reasonable. The pizza was delicious too! You could tell that the ingredients were all fresh, and the dough is made there, not frozen. I think I will definitely be a regular customer here. You gotta try this place!