Latest Reviews
-
The place is now called The Heat, but the pie here is great. I've only had a better deep dish in Chicago. This place is better than Giordanos, a Chi-t…
Jacob Winkler
Humble Pie Pizzeria
-
Ive never been to a pizza place where both the New York and the Chicago style were excellent. Well this place is a first. They absolutely nailed the C…
Brian
Humble Pie Pizzeria
-
If you are a lover of deep dish pizzas or looking for a very fulfilling pizza, Humble Pie is a pretty good place to start! They pride themselves in De…
Allyssa Evergreen (Arissa)
Humble Pie Pizzeria
About
Humble Pie Pizzeria serves Italian and Pizza. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
wificraft beerReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
8 Reviews on “Humble Pie Pizzeria”
Ive never been to a pizza place where both the New York and the Chicago style were excellent. Well this place is a first. They absolutely nailed the Chicago deep dish. The New York pizza is not exactly authentic it was a little thicker and fluffier than Im used to but the flavors were fantastic. Service was excellent. Its a nondescript little place and nothing fancy inside but you wont care!!
If you are a lover of deep dish pizzas or looking for a very fulfilling pizza, Humble Pie is a pretty good place to start! They pride themselves in Deep Dish Chicago-style pizzas. It is a very small restaurant and can only seat a handful of people, so be prepared to wait if you are arriving on a Friday or Saturday night! The servers and manager was friendly and prompt with our orders and food delivery. We ordered their meatball appetizer and a Meat Lover’s Deep Dish Pizza. The Meatball appetizer was large and soaking in sauce; for a meatball, it was pleasantly seasoned and cooked enough where it is not raw but isn’t crumbling underneath your fork. The deep dish pizza took about 40 minutes to make (they make it fresh and oven it), which we didn’t mind the wait. While I did enjoy the meat and cheese in the meal, I was not very partial to the pizza essentially covered and soaking in sauce as well. I felt like there could have been more cheese and ingredients to offset how much sauce there was. One of my favorite parts in the dish though was the crispy and thick crust, but that could just be me being a fan of oven baked crust/bread. All in all, it is not a bad place to start if you are interested in tasting deep dish pizza. The prices are a little steep for the meals, but it is not bad for a once in awhile try! -June 2016
I would say that the best way to describe Humble Pie pizza is, inconsistent. I only order the New York style, but I change the toppings up. When it is good, it is as good as pizza can get, but the hipster cook staff can’t keep it up. Service is sub-par and borderline unprofessional. Salads are overpriced and lame. I ordered a Caesar salad and it had tomatoes!! That is like a calling a cheeseburger a pizza just because is had bread, meat, and cheese. Just call it a side salad. Don’t lie about how fancy you are. Your name is ‘Humble Pie’! Please lose the highfalutin emo local pride and focus on the food. . Oh, how I want them to be as good as their potential. All that being said… I am going to order a large cheese again tonight. (Carry out). If you need a sit-down pizza, go to Hideaway.
Raised in Chicago. If your looking for Lou Malnitis. This is not it. HARDLY ANY MEAT, on the sausage pizza. Sauce was decent. Crust was good but it wasn’t filling pizza. Sevice was great !
This is probably one of the slowest places I have been to in a long time. It was only about half full when I arrived. I was seated at a dirty counter with no effort to clean it. I’m guessing it’s been a few days since it was cleaned judging by the napkin remnants and other food debris. I was talked into ordering an appetizer because the pizza would take about 35 minutes. I nearly walked out because I never got any appetizer until about 30 minutes later. 2 minutes later my pizza arrived. The server blamed the kitchen, but I think she shoud have been paying better attention. The Pizza was decent. I can’t say anything bad about it. For a vegetarian dish it sure filled me up. I doubt I would come back. It seemed like most of the patrons were waiting excessively for food. I had plenty of time to observe.
Meat Lovers. Grilled cheese with bread crumbs!27 Feb, 2015Awesome grilled cheese with crunchy bread crumbs a must have. New on the menu!
Thick Pizza. People talk about this place all the time, So I have tried them three times all three times equal a Strike for poorness, so They failed all three times. three different Pizzas, three bad experiences. Save yourself, just order from Pizza Inn ! some of their pies are like 4 inches of slop with a fancy name, Sure it is 15 pounds of sauces, meat and cheese, but do your colon a favor, just eat one piece. If you eat the whole thing plan on camping out by the toilet at night ! 1 out of 10 stars !