Latest Reviews
-
Reminds me of hideaway with a tiny sprinkle of cici's. Better than most of delivery, but far short of the many great Tulsa pizzaria's. Specifically th…
Mike Broyles
Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery
-
Second visit to Harvard location this time for a carry out. Ordered large pizza with 3 additional toppings at $2.25 per topping. We had 1 1/2 slices o…
Mantodr
Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery
-
Some of these reviews are very old. We have eaten here often. The Confluence pizza is very good and so are the House and Signature salads. We have had…
Paula Ridenour
Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery
About
Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery serves Desserts, Italian and Pizza. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
deliverytakeaway availableReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
8 Reviews on “Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery”
Second visit to Harvard location this time for a carry out. Ordered large pizza with 3 additional toppings at $2.25 per topping. We had 1 1/2 slices of pepperoni and could not taste the additional feta at all. The added topping of black olives was ok. This was a total rip/off. Probably won’t be back, as we drove by 3 other pizza stores to get robbed by this one.
Some of these reviews are very old. We have eaten here often. The Confluence pizza is very good and so are the House and Signature salads. We have had good sandwiches also. The staff is friendly and the food is served quickly.
This is really good pizza. Dough and crust on the hand tossed is so soft. Good sauce to cheese ratio. Definitely will have it again. It’s worth it if youre in the area.
Had three pizzas so far the iron city all meat was a man pizza for sure. The buffalo chicken was decent but the bacon chicken ranch set it off we loved everything about it and the crust was all devoured no bones here!!
Best Pizza in Oklahoma. The pizza is unbelievably awesome! All of the ingredients taste fresh and everything on the menu is consistently delicious every time. The signature salad is another must-have. The people who work here know what excellent customer service is and are friendly and outgoing. If it isn’t enough to have the BEST pizza with great service, they have Maagie Moos ice cream. If you have never been to this pizza joint, it is worth a trip.
Not worth it. Difficulty in taking order over the phone, late delivery the pizza which was cold, didn’t bring the entire order and then of course the pizza was adequate at best. I won’t bother giving them a second chance
Gross–gag. Gross- our pizza was doughy and undercooked! We showed the owner? and he just sort of laughed it off – but he did offer to replace it. None the less – we felt like they didn’t care about our business. We were not offered anything for our inconvenience or even so much as an apology. They are going downhill and we certainly will NOT be returning!!