Latest Reviews
-
Most people still know it as 'The Oakwood'. Why they altered the name a couple years ago, I can't understand. Ordered a Reuben for pickup and it didn'…
Walken4life
McGarrey’s Oakwood Cafe
-
Confusing, dirty, poorly cooked bland food.. My wife and I went here for lunch the other day during a family celebration. First of all, if you're look…
Fooderific
McGarrey’s Oakwood Cafe
-
Up and Down. Sometimes its great...sometimes its not. Maybe its my imagination, but the food in the bar tastes better than the food in the dining room…
Duane Wetick
McGarrey’s Oakwood Cafe
About
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe serves American, Italian and Sandwich. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
indoor seatingsports barwifiReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “McGarrey’s Oakwood Cafe”
Food is sub-par and place is dirty. The food is horrible and the place is dirty. Save your money and eat elsewhere. I don’t usually write negative reviews but this place was a total disappointment.
Always been a great place. Reuben’s are always good.
Since moving to Erie we have wanted to stop in and eat at McGarrey’s. We finally stopped in and we’re very glad we did. Casual, kid friendly and great food!
Order the Reuben. I always get the Reuben sandwich and it is huge! I eat one half there and get a container to take the other half home for another meal.
Delicious soup, the rueben was in charge. Good atmosphere, great service.
Not good.. This is slop. It is not possible to charge so little and have quality ingredients. People like cheap and dont know how to cook so they like Oakwood. There Rueben was good 20 years ago. Not now.
Wow, I forgot how much we like it here.. We get up to Erie a couple of time a year and are always impressed with the food and service. I had a T-Bone steak that was perfectly cooked, and the mashed potatoes were very good. The next day we had the Wedding soup. It was the best (really) Wedding soup we have ever had.