A Slice of Brooklyn Pizzeria

Latest Reviews


  • Gluten free eater. Not good for gluten free food, especially the pizza. Both of got sick from the pizza. Found out it was prepared with same sauce, ch…

  • Horrible food. The wings were hard & like rubber, the pizza was dry & unfavorable, the chicken buffalo Stromboli was like a calzone with a mushy botto…

  • The Best in Lancater. Slice of Brooklyn has the best Steaks and Pizza around. Being from Phila., they have the greatest food.....not greasy and tough.…


About

A Slice of Brooklyn Pizzeria serves Italian, Pizza and Sandwich. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


outdoor seatingwifi

Reviews

8 Reviews on “A Slice of Brooklyn Pizzeria”

Excellent
4.5
8 reviews
  • Akise

    Horrible food. The wings were hard & like rubber, the pizza was dry & unfavorable, the chicken buffalo Stromboli was like a calzone with a mushy bottom & little to no chicken, the manicotti top was hard & the cheese inside was watery & bland. This was a horrible take- out experience!! First time & definately last time!!! Don’t go here!!!

  • Bbenjamin344

    The Best in Lancater. Slice of Brooklyn has the best Steaks and Pizza around. Being from Phila., they have the greatest food…..not greasy and tough…..theyre food is the best. Pleasant employees and waitresses.Thanks…….One from Lancaster.

  • Foodie4Life

    Really, really awesome pizza. Best white pizza I’ve ever had. Just truly disappointing they do not deliver. I have a little one and am forced to order from other pizza places when I can’t run out to pick it up bc she’s in bed. BRING YOUR DELIVERY BACK PLEASE!!!!

  • Cat557

    Best pizza, friendly service. My boyfriend and I just moved up to Lancaster county after living on the Main Line, which has fantastic restaurants, while Lanco has slim pickings. Out of those choice few restaurants, the one place that we go back time and again is A Slice of Brooklyn. Their taco pizza is one of the best I’ve ever had and I’m always full and happy when I leave there. Great prices too!

  • Gmomtat

    Grandma pizza. I eat here almost every weekday for lunch. I love the atmosphere. The vibe is very upbeat just what I need for the middle of the day pick me up. I have ordered pizza to pasta and I have never been disappointed. The staff seems happy to be working and the food shows it. Try the grandma pizza love it!

  • Kimberlyherzing

    What happened??. Quality has diminished. We used to love your pizza. We ordered once a week. Dough seems frozen now and the sauce has changed. Quality has gone down to sub par.

  • Nothings Done

    Good but loud.. The pizza was good and fresh, but the music was so loud it was unbearable. We just ate as fast as we could and left. Will get it to go next time.

Leave a Review

(717) 509-4444

Directions

1750 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top