Latest Reviews
-
New York style, buttery crust cooked well. Lunch specials during the week. Had a large meat lovers, the chicken bacon ranch will be next trip. You nee…
Chuck
Nicky’s Pizzeria
-
Very good! We are new in town and trying out new restaurants. We will be back!! Very authentic.…
Thomas T.
Nicky’s Pizzeria
-
Sicilian Pie. Horrible. I got the Sicilian to go, and my husband got 2 regular slices. For some reason, they put a paper plate over the Sicilian slice…
Susupper
Nicky’s Pizzeria
About
Nicky's Pizzeria serves Italian, Pizza and Sandwich. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Reviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “Nicky’s Pizzeria”
Easily best pizza in town, aaaand best Italian sandwich I’ve ever had and it’s huge! The owners are very cool as well
Service was prompt & polite. The slices were hot and tasty. Great pizza joint. Beer is served in plastic cups and the selection isn’t expansive. Thin slice of pepperoni was greasy, still tasted great. Sicilian was a thick, square piece of crust, crunchy & soft–the bread is my favorite part of pizza, so right up my alley! You can add toppings to your Sicilian for $0.45 each. Yummy stuff.
My favorite spot for pizza… Without question. You won’t be disappointed.
Pizza like back home. Nicky’s has THE BEST pizza in Columbia hands down? Steve and the crew bring a piece of New York to Columbia? The pizza is perfection, sandwiches are amazing, salads are divine. Ask for the cannolis….you will fall in love at first bite! As soon as you walk in and hear the crew speak….you know it’s authentic New York style pizza!,,,
BEST PIZZA AND CUSTOMER SERVICE. Absolutely the best pizza in Columbia! I love to have pizzas deliverd to my son during exam week or say….. St. Patricks Day and these guys are THE BEST with getting their awesome food delivered and in customer service! Thanks Nickys!
The Stromboli and pesto cheese bread were right on time!!! People may tell you to go to pizza man. Skip it, and alternate between village and nicky’s instead!
No need to travel to NYC.. it came here. I’m not a pizza gourmet critic, however, I’ve sampled pizza in the heralded pizza capitals of Chicago, New York City, and San Francisco and Nicky’s Sicilian pie takes no back seat. Generous toppings, excellent crust and served with friendliness.