Latest Reviews
-
Good pizza, good service and cold beer. Need I say more...ok I will. Great casual place to grab some NY style pizza after a hot day out at the beach.…
Lindsey Anthony
Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs
-
Our Service was ok. The atmosphere was nothing special. Our sausage and green pepper pizza was rather bland. The sausage was sliced sausage and flavor…
Regina
Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs
-
Most incredible pizza, ever! We ordered the pepperoni, garlic, and basil pizza. Had enough to take back to our condo and devoured the rest during lunc…
Stephenie Griffith
Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs
About
Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs serves Pizza and Sandwich. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Reviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
9 Reviews on “Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs”
Most incredible pizza, ever! We ordered the pepperoni, garlic, and basil pizza. Had enough to take back to our condo and devoured the rest during lunch the next day. We will return for a pizza to go on our way back home!
Finally!!! I found a pizza on this island that I actually want to eat. The Py Pie is spot on for flavor and crust quality. Fresh garlic and basil with pepperoni on a thin crispy crust that is foldable….Boom! Drop the mic. (Pick the mic back up). We also got an Italian hoagie that was good…
I’d have to say that this was what I was looking forward to most on the island. The pizza is some of the best anywhere, and the subs are loaded with meat and toppings. They have a great full bar and everyone there was great.
This used to be one of our favorites, but we were so disappointed this last visit. The pizza was so so, the service was horrible. We were in a mid section with servers all around, but somehow we were forgotten. It wasn’t crowded at the time. We probably won’t return there.
Removed by reviewer.
Slow service, really really slow. People were waiting at least 20 minutes. Pepperoni pizza had 2 pepperonis. I didn’t find this out until I had gone back to my condo, 20 minutes away. Try someplace else.
Worth the visit. Note new address: 1034 William Hilton Parkway. The kids loved their food, the ambience, and the coloring sheet that they were invited to tape to the wall. We enjoyed the eggplant parmesan and a pizza slice, but found the food wait to be ridiculously long and it wasn’t busy when we placed our order. Would definitely go again.