The Sweet Tooth Fairy

5 Reviews on “The Sweet Tooth Fairy”

• Drbarber60

  01/23/2015. My wife asked me to Stop by Sweet Tooth Fairy to pick up some desert for her Book Club meeting. I am just a dumb guy, so, I didn’t know what I was getting into by honoring this seemingly simple request. She originally requested a Baker’s Dozen of Bars and Brownies (she said they’ll know what you’re talking about). When I placed the order, the the associated helping me treated me like I was some sort of idiot. I called my wife for clarification. It seems they only had Lemon Bars and Foxy Bars. My Wife instructed me to purchase four Lemon Bars and four Foxy Bars and a Baker’s Dozen on Cake Bites. I of course, carried out her order as instructed. Man, I was in all kinds of big trouble when I presented her with her order. Dude gave me a greasy box with lots of greasy finger prints, all over it, no parchment paper (I understand that prevents greasy marks and no cover on the box. She told me she absolutely could not take that package to book club. She was running late and had to repackage the entire order in her own Pyrex pan…with parchment paper. And, I was told the desert was not a hit. I won’t be going back ever. Good luck!

  April 24, 2015, 4:42 am

  Log in to Reply
• Kristan Ross Davies

  Sugar anyone?. I was very excited to try Sweet Tooth Fairy’s cupcakes today. Previously I had sampled the PB Chocolate, at a birthday party, which is outstanding. Unfortunately all of the other varieties are sickly sweet. Like shake your head roll your stomach saccharine. The frosting is very dense and thick, overwhelming the cake in flavor, texture, and pure volume. My pick, The toasted coconut, had no coconut flavor. Pure sugar bomb. My husbands cookies and cream cupcake was less sweet, but still overboard. You could barely taste the chocolate and not a hint of any creaminess anywhere. the good news? the triple chocolate cookie I got for my daughter had great chocolate flavor…deep, smoky, coffee like dark chocolate flavor.

  March 3, 2012, 2:31 am

  Log in to Reply
• Woffo

  Good for a Cupcake Fix. While I do think they are overpriced, they know how to make good cookies and cupcakes. I’ll spend the money when I don’t have time to make my own. The perfect place if you’ve got a sweet tooth.

  March 2, 2012, 6:07 am

  Log in to Reply
• Tami

  Amazing Customer Service. I cannot say enough about The Sweet Tooth Fairy! Aside from the amazing cupcakes and desserts, the customer service is one of a kind. My Mom is Gluten-Free and they special made cupcakes for her, which were amazing! The owner made a VERY large donation for an event this summer without hesitation, EMHE was incredibly appreciative. I HIGHLY recommend to everyone, my only complaint is that I can’t have cupcakes shipped to all of our out of town family that loves them!

  December 9, 2011, 11:08 pm

  Log in to Reply
• Riverrunner

  Clean ever?. Their floors, tables and couches were just covered in filth. I was blown away. Who wants to eat like that? Make someone keep the dining room area clean please.Besides that, their cupcakes are far from the best I’ve had. The German Chocolate had a weird licorice flavor in it I could not stand. The others we tried were okay tasting, but their frosting is just too heavy here. It’s stomach ache inducing. A downer all around.

  October 16, 2010, 2:01 am

  Log in to Reply