Latest Reviews
-
Their thin-crust pizza was closer to a Brooklyn-style than an actual thin crust, which I honestly preferred more. Though I'm not a fan of deep-dish du…
Danny Chung
Nicolitalia Pizzeria
-
Definitely the best pizza in Provo. I've heard friends say that the service can be slow and unreliable, but it's always been good for me. Eye of the T…
Gavin McMahan
Nicolitalia Pizzeria
-
Visiting from out of town and We tried this place based on the positive feedback and found it to be very sub par. Ordered a margarita pizza with peppe…
Julie Flynn-Cordova
Nicolitalia Pizzeria
About
Nicolitalia Pizzeria is open for Casual Dining. Nicolitalia Pizzeria serves Italian and Pizza dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
deliveryoutdoor seatingwifino alcohol availableReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
10 Reviews on “Nicolitalia Pizzeria”
Their thin-crust pizza was closer to a Brooklyn-style than an actual thin crust, which I honestly preferred more. Though I’m not a fan of deep-dish due to personal biases (having lived in the Bronx for a number of years), the other option, with pepperoni, wasn’t too shabby. I’d like to explore this place’s menu a little bit more in the future.
Definitely the best pizza in Provo. I’ve heard friends say that the service can be slow and unreliable, but it’s always been good for me. Eye of the Tiger is unreal.
Visiting from out of town and We tried this place based on the positive feedback and found it to be very sub par. Ordered a margarita pizza with pepperoni. The pizza crust looked like none of the pictures. The edge was non existent. The sauce was stewed tomatoes in huge chunks out of the can with no basil and no seasoning or flavor with tons of cheese. We also ordered buffalo wings that had no buffalo wing sauce but rather a funky sauce that tasted like honey vinegar and chili powder. Also ordered a Greek salad that was beautiful but the dressing wasn’t Greek or Italian. It tasted like a mixture of left overs. Yuck. Never again!