Latest Reviews
-
I Keep Returning. If service was half as bad as some describe, I wouldn't keep returning. As a former RR car converted to diner, it can become crowded…
Bill11w21
The Madison Diner
-
The food is great. Service has never been very good. After seating at the counter on a busy Sunday after half an hour we had to ask where our food was…
Jeff Holt
The Madison Diner
-
Good NW style breakfast. Good value, generous portions so you can save some for later. I had two large cornmeal pancakes, eggs, and what tasted like h…
Clubmud
The Madison Diner
About
The Madison Diner is open for Diner. The Madison Diner serves American and Breakfast dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
takeaway availableoutdoor seatingwifiindoor seatingdog friendlyReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
9 Reviews on “The Madison Diner”
Good NW style breakfast. Good value, generous portions so you can save some for later. I had two large cornmeal pancakes, eggs, and what tasted like home made patty sausage. Neat authentic diner built in the 40’s and shipped to bainbridge is in the 90’s. Service was good.
A classic diner with great food. We have eaten here for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Breakfast is busy but we’ll worth the wait. I always eat the pancake combo. It sticks to my ribs and is fabulous!
Awesome burger. I had an awesome mushroom swiss burger there today, best burger I have had in a while, after arriving too late for Cafe Nola, which was a good thing, I think. Nice juicy, made with good quality meat and cooked perfectly. Madison Diner might be a new favourite, they don’t close at 3! Oh, and the cooks are cute! Nice to have some eye-candy to watch while waiting for my food. 😉 Wait service was a little slow, but they were busy. Nice and polite though, and he food was great. Definitely would go back.
Slow service – actually beyond slow! Empty tables galore and no one bussing or seating. Tables blocking access to bathrooms – so not ADA compliant! With 6 people they added 18% took 30 minutes to get our food – every thing was greasy, waitstaff was slow and not very responsive. Had the swiss-burger – not exceptional – overall not worth your time.
This is the ultimate diner! Was worried after some reviews but tried it on our first visit to the island. It was very busy and we had to wait about 15mi. All of our meals were amazing–they do breakfast to perfection. French toast, thick bacon, pancakes, eggs, hashbrowns. Family ordered the club and French dip sandwiches, they were also amazing. The staff is sweet and very busy so u might have to ask twice but the food and cute train car atmosphere made up for it.
Sloppy with cold meal. After 3 owners and name changes we tried again to like this cute little diner.Well how do you like the long greasy hair and tattoos preparing dinner? Not much more than I like the too casual servers who were busy chatting with each other.Ordering that Amrican comfort food staple, Mac and Cheese on a cold night seemed like logic. After a long wait the dish was served ice cold in the middle. It took a long time to get it corrected and the second time around it smelled so badly of something burned I expected the smoke alarm to go off.This place lacks a manager to train and supervise inexperienced staff.
A Tastey Treat. Just came from The Madison Diner. What a tasty treat. Had the Turkey melt on sourdough. Gooey cheese, grilled onions just to the point of sweetness, bacon firm but not fall apart crunchy and turkey carved just right. A little potato salad on the side and a glass of ice tea. Served by friendly and efficient wat staff. Highly recommend. Next time it’s the hand dipped cholcolate malted!