Latest Reviews


  • Family dinner at Marty's in Brookfield. First time back since eating here as a kid after baseball games in late 80's. Took extended family to Sunday d…

  • So far in 50/50 with this place. Chicken Alfredo was great! Big portion, lots of chicken and plenty of sauce! Got the Veal Parmesan and it was awful. …

  • I'll pass. It's always nice to have a local place to go to grab something in a pinch. This is no longer it for me. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to pick…


About

Marty's Pizza Pasta & Subs serves Italian and Pizza. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details



Feature List


deliverytakeaway available

Reviews

8 Reviews on “Marty’s Pizza Pasta & Subs”

Excellent
4.8
8 reviews
  • Lance

    So far in 50/50 with this place. Chicken Alfredo was great! Big portion, lots of chicken and plenty of sauce! Got the Veal Parmesan and it was awful. Spaghetti noodles were over cooked and tasted kinda like dishwater and way to much cheese. Have to pick and choose what I get here I spose.

  • Walt60

    I’ll pass. It’s always nice to have a local place to go to grab something in a pinch. This is no longer it for me. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to pick up. The box was soaked with grease and the food was warm dry and hard. I suspect it was floating around in one of their trucks most of the evening.

  • James

    Stuck in the 60’s. Well, what can I say. Its from the old days, uninspired pizza. The steak sandwich was tough and the bread was cheap (granted it was not a sub). I was surprised at the prices also, they seem high for what your getting. The staff seemed unhappy and overall it had a dingy feel. I think I would have rather gone to pizza hut.

  • J123

    Horrible. Pizza was extremly greasy. Spicy BBQ chicken pizza didnt even taste like BBQ sauce – rather a blah flavorless sauce with hardly a hint of spicyness to it. Garlic toast tasted of pure salt . Called to complain and was offered to send something else out, would have rather been given a refund as it was 11 at night and had already waited 40 minutes for delivery to our hotel, but agreed to try some pasta, also flavorless with the exception of salt. Very nice staff (delivery driver and manager) but honestly the worst pizza/pasta we have ever had.

  • Ashley

    Great restaurant! Went out of their way to make sure we were happy and had a great experience. Thank you!

  • Danielle Jorgensen

    Place is great & pizza is really good. Can get busy Saturday evenings but that’s to be expected. Variety of pizzas, pastas, & subs. Pizzas are a good price for how large they are. Ingredients taste fresh & they put plenty of toppings on it. We also tried the Jack & Blue cheese sticks with buffalo sauce & they were really good & would recommend trying them at least once. I would deffinately go back to Marty’s Pizza.

  • Therese Kurszewski

    The folks who work there are very nice. The pizza is edible. Didn’t care for their pasta with marinara sauce. Next time I’ll stick to the pizza.

Leave a Review

(262) 782-5830

Directions

16630 W Bluemound Rd, Brookfield, WI 53005

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top