Latest Reviews


  • A little slice of Italy in the Fox Valley. We went for a fun weekend lunch with a little dessert and were not disappointed. The ravioli and pappardell…

  • Amazing food and atmosphere!!! Absolutely loved this place. Everything was delicious and the staff excellent. I would go back every day!!!!!!!…

  • So Good!. I have been to this restaurant around 20 times and I have yet to find something less than amazing on the menu or ingredients that aren't per…


About

Carmella's Italian Bistro serves Italian. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details


Reviews

9 Reviews on “Carmella’s Italian Bistro”

Excellent
5
9 reviews
  • Charles Johnson

    So Good!. I have been to this restaurant around 20 times and I have yet to find something less than amazing on the menu or ingredients that aren’t perfectly fresh. This was Italian on a similar level of quality and authenticity as I experienced on my trip to Italy. Also, the ariana is so good.

  • LFZ

    No big deal. Pan fried mozzarella was good — but nothing special. Chicken & Sausage Scarpierello was much too sharp, either from too much wine, too much lemon, or both — and the sausage was simply very small slivers of sausage. Mine is much better.09 Nov, 2014Nothing to write home about. Pan fried mozz was good, but nothing special. Chicken / Sausage scarpierello left a lot to be desired. Sausage was just skinny little slivers. Sauce was SO sharp – not sure if from too much wine, too much lemon juice, or both. Mine is much better.

  • Pillaro

    Underwhelmed. Was at carmellas on 7/26/14, service was good, but food was marginal .

  • Marcia K

    This place was phenomenal!!! Anti pasti appetizer was great!!! Highly recommend. This was my first time. And I can’t wait to go back!!!

  • KLowe

    Friendly, knowledgeable staff, nice atmosphere. Food was excellent and well worth it. My only gripe is the menus are big compared to the table.

  • Steve

    Very good food and nice atmosphere. No bar, just wine and beer, and kind of an awkward location but overall VERY satisfied.

  • HickoryWind

    This is absolutely fantastic. I was staying downntown but made a point to drive out after reading the reviews. It was some of the best Italian I have had anywhere. Superb service!

Leave a Review

(920) 882-4044

Directions

716 north casaloma drive, Appleton, WI 54913

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top