Geno Nottolini’s Pizza
Latest Reviews
-
Delivery Order. Food was accurate fast and efficient. Friendly staff and delivery driver. Only disappointment was Canolli. I ordered one for dessert a…
Brewag
Geno Nottolini’s Pizza
-
Horrible service and under cooked pizza. Ordered a family size new york style pizza. The pizza was horrible, the bottom of the crust was done and then…
Melkay22
Geno Nottolini’s Pizza
-
Yum. Good food. And we'll priced. I like the new place and the bar. Nice friendly people…
Ryandjaz
Geno Nottolini’s Pizza
About
Geno Nottolini's Pizza is open for Fast Casual. Geno Nottolini's Pizza serves Italian, Pizza and Bar Food dishes. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!Details
Feature List
deliverytakeaway availablelive musicindoor seatingno alcohol availableReviews
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to post a comment.
7 Reviews on “Geno Nottolini’s Pizza”
Delivery Order. Food was accurate fast and efficient. Friendly staff and delivery driver. Only disappointment was Canolli. I ordered one for dessert and found it only filled on the edges. The middle was empty. I called and was told this is the way they make them. Disappointing to pay 2.35 and get a hollow shell.
Horrible service and under cooked pizza. Ordered a family size new york style pizza. The pizza was horrible, the bottom of the crust was done and then there was an entire layer of uncooked dough!!! Out of 7 people everyone threw their piece away. When i called to complain they told me I must not of ever had new york style pizza (my husband is from new york) and the only way they would replace the pizza was if I brought in the half of pizza I had left and I would also have to bring in all of the pieces from the trash! I didn’t want to bring in half eaten pieces from the trash so they said they would not replace the pizza unless they had every piece. Will never eat there again!
Yum. Good food. And we’ll priced. I like the new place and the bar. Nice friendly people
Poor service, sat without water for 15 minutes with only 3 tables occupied. Cooks could not do a half and half pizza…Pizza was good though
Geno Notillini’s Pizza on Indiana Ave.. We arrived at 11:30 am and no one in sight except a man working on painting. We took a table and looked at the menus provided at the table. Still no one around, my friend walked around the bar to see if she could see someone. Now you would think that they were taking a risk leaving everything open to the public with no one out front at the bar. 10 min later we got acknowledged and order took. I had the steak sandwich that tasted freezer burned. Fries were good. My friend had the Ricks special with fries and it was good. Got the bill and they never came back to collect so we left the money and tip on table and left. Won’t go back to dine in.
Depends on the day. Some days it’s delivered hot. More often it’s late and cold. Not many non chain options deliver here so they’ve been our go-to option for years. Have finally had enough of them and their horrible customer service. Frozen pizza from here on.
Cheap and easy. For a buck a slice it may not be worth it if you are eating a whole lot but for a quick lunch its nice. Pizza quality is so-so, about as good as a high quality frozen pizza. I’ll likely be back.