Latest Reviews


  • Hands down the best gyros in the area.The owner grows some ingredients herself and you can tell.My only complaint is their hours.They open late during…

  • Very happy. We traveled from Watertown to try this place out, mainly because of our love for Greek food. The flaming cheese was good for an appetizer,…

  • Updated review. Still like/love the food but it's over priced and I am always hungry. We haven't been in as much because if this. The fries are great …


About

Atlantis Taverna serves Greek and Mediterranean. Incorrect or missing information? Make a report, or claim the restaurant if you own it!

Details


Reviews

9 Reviews on “Atlantis Taverna”

Excellent
4.7
9 reviews
  • Cydogg

    Updated review. Still like/love the food but it’s over priced and I am always hungry. We haven’t been in as much because if this. The fries are great but they are so stingy with the amount that you get. I got 14 fries with my recent take out order. I also ordered extra meat and it looked just like regular meat for extra $$.

  • Mad Foodie

    Delicious and Exceeds Sun Prairie Standards. Many of the restaurants in Sun Prairie are not worth the money or the time. I moved to the area in part because I could walk to many local establishments. Sadly, almost all have proven beyond disappointing. I drive into Madison or even to Milwaukee for a good meal, but Atlantis Taverna is the EXCEPTION! I have eaten in the restaurant and had take out many times and every meal was delicious. Great for vegetarians and meat eaters alike. Kind service and delicious food. Everyone in Sun Prairie should eat here and it is well worth the drive for those in neighboring communities.

  • Christine Dwyer

    So awesome!

  • Jo Hilsheimer

    Of you are looking for a hearty meal but one that doesn’t leave you full in the bad sense of the word: this is the place. Combining our meals my partner and I were able to try all of the different style meats they had to offer. Plus their side dishes as well. Food was great. From the chicken to the gyro meat, It was all tender and had great seasoning. Wonderful beer and wine selection as well as a knowledgeable staff to guide your choice— very handy when it came to the ouzo. Staff was helpful and, even though we came in an hour before closing time, made us feel very welcome. I highly recommend you stop by and try it out. I know I will be back.

  • David

    We stumbled into this place late on a Wednesday night after not receiving timely service at another local establishment. The service here was top notch. The location on Main Street is easily accessible and pleasant. The decor, aroma, and overall feel of Atlantis was warm, inviting, and very appealing. The food; well, I’ve had no better Greek food than the dishes at Atlanis. The meats were cooked perfectly, retaining flavor and juices. The pork and chicken were of the same caliber. We had appetizers that were delicious and an exceptional value. And we topped it all off with Ouzo recommended by our server that finished our meals perfectly.

  • Ncl1313

    Not good. Perhaps I need to try again, but my first visit last year left me severely disappointed and I haven’t been back. Spanakopita was soggy and tasteless. The Tyrokafteri (red pepper and feta dip) was the wrong consistency. Tzatziki was watery. Gyro and Souvlaki meats were dry. Flaming Saganaki was good, but it’s really hard to screw that up. Service was very personal, but we were one of only 2 tables there at 6:30pm on a Wednesday. I’ll definitely need some convincing in order to go back…

  • Grittyj

    Gyro, Gyro, Gyro. Best Gyros in the area. I dare say I preferred them to Parthenon’s. Frat boys and drunkards may take exception to this claim, but foodies should agree.

Leave a Review

(608) 837-5700

Directions

239 E Main St, Sun Prairie, WI 53590

Own this Business?

Claim your business to manage photos, menus, details, advertise, and plenty more!

Issues?

Notice anything wrong with this listing? Please report issues/suggestions here.

Scroll to Top